Looking to Sell

Are you cleaning out your closet? Then try one of our Nab Bags! You can now sell us your clothes and accessories by filling them and shipping them back to us. Plus, with our new PayPal payouts, you can get paid quicker than ever!

Are you cleaning out your garage, have electronics you no longer need, or toys the kids no longer play with? Get a box pack them and we will send you a shipping label.

Once we receive your bag or box, it will take 3-4 weeks from start to finish. For any items we’re able to buy, we’ll assign them a price and then pay out 25% of that in cash (check or PayPal) or 50% in a Store Trade Card. If you do have a Buffalo Exchange near you, we always recommend selling in-store.

Looking to Donate

Donating your unpurchased items is a great way to give back to the community and feel even better about your cleanout! Through our Clothing for the Community® program, Southern Arizona non-profit organizations can receive large clothing donations from Sell By Mail. Charities then use this donation of clothing and accessories to generate money for their organization by hosting a $1 Sale. Variations of this program have raised $40,591 since 2015.

What about the items we can’t buy?

For any items we’re unable to buy, you can have them returned to you for a $14.99 shipping fee or donate them to a good cause through our Clothing for the Community® program. Please choose carefully when you request a bag, as you won’t be able to change this later. Unfortunately, we’re unable to offer tax receipts.

More About Returns

If you’d like to have your unpurchased items returned to you, you’ll need to pay a $14.99 shipping & handling fee. When we finish processing your items, we’ll direct you to a link to make this payment.